June 24, 2008agrarian distressagricultureeconomic policyEconomyfarmersIndiaMaharashtraPublic Policyrural development

Goodbye cotton, hello soyabean

The rational farmers of Maharashtra

This is an archived blog post from The Acorn.

Just how does P Sainath position facts that show how Maharashtra’s farmers are capitalising on the opportunity created by rising global foodgrain prices? Oh, by saying that they are replacing one type of volatility (planting cotton) by another (soyabeans).

After pointing out how farmers are reaping the benefits of growing soyabeans, he goes on to point out the risks of growing soyabeans, and the dangers of planting the same crop season after season. As if there are crops that somehow defy these risks.

Mr Sainath, unsurprisingly, fails to underline three really important points: first, that given a chance, farmers can help themselves by taking advantage of available opportunities. Second, information about prices, weather and market conditions enabled this. And third, following from the above, just letting them do what they like (and not placing value judgements on what they should grow) is the best solution.

Related post: Rising foodgrain prices present an opportunity for Indian farmers

If you would like to share or comment on this, please discuss it on my GitHub Previous
The game continues

© Copyright 2003-2024. Nitin Pai. All Rights Reserved.