September 22, 2019philosophydebates with my daughters

Morals, laws and meat

Where my daughter challenges me on dietary preferences and fundamental rights

Deccan Herald This is from my Debates with My Daughters column that appeared in the Deccan Herald in 2019-20

Dinner table debates at the Pai household increasingly result in the two teenage girls rolling their eyes at the primitive moral standards of their opinionated father. They believe that their parents — especially their father — need education in appreciating music, discerning fashion, accepting proper social norms, using the internet properly, deciphering what they consider modern English and, quite obviously, in saving the planet. Sometimes I think they have a point. In any case, I hope sharing some of these conversations with you, dear reader, will serve a greater public purpose and win you over to my side. Some time ago, Airy, the younger of the two girls and the rebel star of the family, declared that she wanted to turn vegan. After reading and some reflection she felt that meat and milk products involved avoidable cruelty to animals. Anticipating parental resistance, she argued that as a citizen of India she enjoyed the liberty to choose what she wanted to eat, and offered to cite the articles from the Constitution that guaranteed those rights.

She raised two good questions here: one moral, and the other constitutional.

K T Achaya

The moral argument, as made out by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) is that eating animals is cruel, unsustainable, and unethical, and people should make the switch to vegan eating.” The counter to it is that the human species has been a meat-eating one, across the world, for most of its history and this makes it as natural for us to eat meat as to eat plants. The late K T Achaya, a Bangalorean, has written about the very meat-eating history of Indian food. You could visit the Institute of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine (I-AIM) in Yelahanka and pick up their translation of Raghunatha Suri’s seventeenth-century treatise, Bhojanakutuhalam which has some mindblowing non-vegetarian recipes.

The Moral Arc

If we were to abstain from eating living things, or dead things that were once living, we would have nothing to eat at all. We should plead guilty to charges of cruelty, though, for no matter how natural meat-eating is, killing animals involves taking a life by inflicting pain on a sentient being. While sustainability is a matter of technology and practice — we can improve on that front — cruelty is currently unavoidable. Does this make meat-eating unethical? Or does the fact that it is natural for us to eat meat invalidate such concerns? Michael Shermer who advances the case for moral behaviour determined by science and reason in The Moral Arc argues that the arc of our moral universe is expanding and over history we have been steadily—albeit at times haltingly—expanding the moral sphere to include more members of our species (and now even other species) as legitimate participants in the moral community.”

I conceded that veganism might be a superior ethical position, but, I told the girls, I choose not to be at the leading edge of the moral arc. And if they wished to be, they could do so after they turned eighteen. I will wait for cellular agriculture (‘lab grown meat’) to cultured meat available and our moral arcs to converge.

There are many more Debates with my Daughters here

This brings us to their fundamental rights, which I discovered, is an interesting question. To what extent that can I, as a parent, abridge them? Fundamental rights are enforceable against the state, not against other citizens. But there are provisions in the penal code against wrongful restraint. In practice, Indian courts will upport the parent’s decision on dietary preferences. They might even support the government’s orders on what adults should eat. I would win, I told Airy, if she takes the matter to court against me, through me. The moral victory, though, was hers.

If you would like to share or comment on this, please discuss it on my GitHub Previous
Swalpa controversy
Keep an open mind on genetic tech to snuff out mosquitoes

© Copyright 2003-2024. Nitin Pai. All Rights Reserved.